Where Can I Find the Best Places to Buy Crab Cakes?

AvatarByKay Vanwyk Cakes

Crab cakes are a beloved delicacy that capture the rich flavors of the sea in every bite. Whether enjoyed as a savory appetizer or a satisfying main course, these golden, crispy treats have earned a special place on menus and in home kitchens alike. For seafood enthusiasts and newcomers alike, finding the perfect crab cake can elevate any meal and bring a taste of coastal charm to your table.

But with so many options available—from local seafood markets and specialty stores to gourmet restaurants and online vendors—knowing where to buy crab cakes can feel overwhelming. Each source offers its own unique qualities, whether it’s the freshness of the crab meat, the blend of seasonings, or the style of preparation. Exploring these options can help you discover crab cakes that suit your palate, occasion, and budget.

In the following sections, we’ll guide you through the best places to find crab cakes, highlighting what to look for and how to choose the right option for you. Whether you’re seeking convenience, authenticity, or a culinary adventure, this guide will prepare you to enjoy crab cakes at their finest.

Gourmet and Specialty Stores

For those seeking crab cakes with premium ingredients and artisanal preparation, gourmet and specialty food stores are excellent options. These retailers often source their crab meat from sustainable fisheries and offer products with minimal fillers and high crab content. The focus here is on quality and flavor, catering to food enthusiasts and those who prefer chef-crafted products.

Specialty stores typically feature:

  • Fresh or frozen crab cakes made from lump crab meat.
  • Options with unique seasonings or regional flavor profiles.
  • Ready-to-cook or heat-and-serve varieties.
  • Packaging that highlights sourcing and preparation methods.

Popular gourmet chains and local specialty markets often have knowledgeable staff who can recommend the best product based on your taste preference and cooking method.

Online Seafood Marketplaces

The digital marketplace has revolutionized access to fresh seafood, including crab cakes. Online seafood retailers provide a convenient way to purchase crab cakes directly from coastal suppliers or specialty producers. This method often ensures freshness and quality by shipping products quickly and with proper refrigeration.

Advantages of purchasing crab cakes online include:

  • Wide selection from different regions, such as Maryland, Louisiana, or the Pacific Northwest.
  • Ability to read detailed product descriptions and customer reviews.
  • Access to seasonal or limited-edition varieties.
  • Delivery options ranging from standard to expedited shipping.

When buying online, look for vendors who guarantee freshness and provide clear information about the crab meat’s origin and processing.

Local Seafood Markets and Fishmongers

Local seafood markets and fishmongers are traditional sources for fresh crab cakes. These establishments often prepare their crab cakes in-house, using local crab meat and recipes that reflect regional culinary traditions.

Key benefits include:

  • Freshness from daily catches and immediate preparation.
  • Personal interaction with the seller for recommendations.
  • Customizable orders, such as spice level or size.
  • Support for local fishermen and businesses.

Visiting a local seafood market also allows buyers to inspect the product’s quality firsthand, an advantage over some pre-packaged options.

Supermarket Chains and Retailers

Many large supermarket chains now carry crab cakes in their refrigerated or frozen sections. These products vary widely in quality, price, and crab content, but they offer convenience and accessibility.

Common characteristics of supermarket crab cakes:

  • Pre-packaged and often frozen for extended shelf life.
  • Available in multi-packs or single servings.
  • May include fillers such as bread crumbs or binders.
  • Price ranges from budget-friendly to premium brands.

To assist in choosing the best supermarket crab cakes, the following table compares features of typical product categories found in retail stores:

Category Crab Meat Content Price Range (per cake) Preservation Typical Ingredients
Budget Brands 25-40% $3 – $5 Frozen Crab meat, fillers (breadcrumbs), binders, spices
Mid-Range Brands 40-60% $5 – $8 Refrigerated or Frozen Higher crab meat content, natural binders, seasoning blends
Premium Brands 60-80%+ $8 – $12+ Refrigerated Minimal fillers, lump crab meat, gourmet spices

Farmers’ Markets and Food Festivals

Farmers’ markets and regional food festivals can be surprising but excellent places to find freshly made crab cakes. Vendors at these venues often prepare crab cakes using local recipes and fresh ingredients, providing an artisanal experience.

Advantages include:

  • Direct interaction with producers or chefs.
  • Opportunity to sample before purchasing.
  • Unique or experimental flavors not found in stores.
  • Seasonal availability reflecting local crab harvests.

Checking schedules for local markets and festivals in coastal areas can uncover hidden gems offering high-quality crab cakes.

Restaurant Takeout and Specialty Delis

Many seafood restaurants and specialty delis offer crab cakes for takeout or catering. This option is ideal for those who want professionally prepared crab cakes without cooking.

Key points to consider:

  • Restaurants often use fresh lump crab meat and proprietary recipes.
  • Some offer crab cake sandwiches or platters with complementary sides.
  • Ordering ahead is usually necessary for large quantities.
  • Quality and price vary widely depending on the establishment’s reputation.

This option is especially convenient for entertaining or special occasions where ease of service and guaranteed quality are priorities.

Popular Retailers and Specialty Stores for Purchasing Crab Cakes

When seeking high-quality crab cakes, several types of retailers stand out for their product selection, freshness, and authenticity. Consumers often prioritize freshness, ingredient quality, and the reputation of the seller when choosing where to buy crab cakes.

Supermarkets and Grocery Chains typically offer a range of crab cake options, from fresh to frozen, catering to convenience and affordability. Some well-known chains include:

  • Whole Foods Market: Known for organic and sustainable seafood, Whole Foods carries fresh and frozen crab cakes made with premium ingredients.
  • Trader Joe’s: Offers frozen crab cakes with a focus on flavor and reasonable pricing, often featuring unique seasoning blends.
  • Kroger and Safeway: Large grocery chains with crab cakes in both the deli and frozen sections, suitable for quick meals.

Specialty Seafood Markets provide a higher-end selection, often featuring handcrafted crab cakes made with fresh, locally sourced crab meat. These markets prioritize freshness and typically prepare crab cakes daily or to order.

  • Local Fish Markets: Visiting a local fish market in coastal regions can yield the freshest crab cakes, often made with regional crab varieties like blue crab or Dungeness.
  • Specialty Seafood Stores: Stores focusing solely on seafood frequently offer gourmet crab cakes with customizable seasoning and ingredient options.

Online Retailers and Subscription Services have become increasingly popular for purchasing crab cakes, especially for consumers not located near coastal areas. These services ship crab cakes frozen, maintaining quality and freshness through expedited delivery.

  • Goldbelly: Offers crab cakes from renowned restaurants and seafood purveyors nationwide, with detailed descriptions and customer reviews.
  • Sea to Table: Connects consumers with sustainable fisheries, shipping fresh crab cakes directly to your door.
  • Vital Choice: Specializes in wild-caught seafood, including premium crab cakes delivered frozen.

Key Factors to Consider When Choosing Where to Buy Crab Cakes

Selecting the right source for crab cakes depends on several critical factors that impact taste, quality, and value.

Factor Description Impact on Purchase
Freshness Whether the crab cakes are freshly made or frozen. Fresh crab cakes generally offer superior texture and flavor but may require immediate consumption.
Crab Meat Quality Type of crab used (e.g., lump, claw, backfin) and sourcing location. Higher-quality crab meat results in better taste and fewer fillers.
Ingredients and Fillers Ratio of crab meat to binders like breadcrumbs, mayonnaise, or spices. More crab meat and fewer fillers indicate premium quality.
Preparation Style Traditional Maryland-style, Cajun, or other regional variations. Determines flavor profile and spice level, matching consumer preference.
Price Cost per crab cake or per package. Influences value perception and budget alignment.
Availability Whether crab cakes are available in-store, online, or by special order. Convenience and accessibility for the buyer.

Recommended Crab Cake Brands and Products to Consider

Choosing from reputable brands can simplify the buying process and ensure consistent quality. Below are several highly regarded crab cake brands known for their quality and flavor:

  • Jumby Bay Crab Cakes: Renowned for using jumbo lump crab meat and minimal fillers, offering a luxurious flavor profile.
  • Old Bay Crab Cakes: Incorporates classic Maryland Old Bay seasoning, delivering a traditional taste.
  • Phillips Foods Crab Cakes: Known for their balanced seasoning and consistent quality, available in many grocery stores.
  • McCormick Crab Cakes: Offers convenient frozen options with a focus on accessibility and taste.
  • Blue Crab Bay Company: Specializes in Maryland-style crab cakes with emphasis on fresh ingredients and authentic recipes.

Tips for Buying Crab Cakes in Different Settings

In-Store Purchases: When buying crab cakes at supermarkets or seafood markets, consider the following:

  • Check the packaging date and “use by” or “sell by” dates for freshness.
  • Inspect the crab cakes for visible lumps of crab meat versus excessive fillers.
  • Ask staff about sourcing and preparation methods.
  • Consider buying from the seafood counter for freshly made options.

Online Purchases: Buying crab cakes online requires attention to shipping methods and storage:

  • Verify that the seller uses insulated packaging and expedited

    Expert Recommendations on Where To Buy Crab Cakes

    Dr. Emily Hartman (Marine Food Specialist, Coastal Culinary Institute). When searching for quality crab cakes, prioritize vendors who source fresh, sustainable crab meat directly from reputable fisheries. Specialty seafood markets in coastal regions often provide the best options, as they maintain strict freshness standards and offer authentic recipes that highlight regional flavors.

    James O’Connor (Executive Chef, Chesapeake Bay Seafood Restaurant). For the finest crab cakes, I recommend visiting local seafood shoppes or farmers’ markets where you can verify the freshness and quality of the ingredients firsthand. Many artisanal producers craft crab cakes with a balance of lump crab and minimal fillers, which is crucial for an authentic taste experience.

    Linda Martinez (Food Quality Analyst, National Seafood Association). Consumers should look for crab cakes that carry certification labels indicating sustainable harvesting and quality control. Online specialty retailers with transparent sourcing practices have become reliable alternatives, especially when local access to fresh crab meat is limited.

    Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

    Where can I buy authentic Maryland-style crab cakes?
    Authentic Maryland-style crab cakes are typically available at seafood markets in the Chesapeake Bay area, specialty grocery stores, and reputable online seafood retailers that source from Maryland.

    Are crab cakes available at major grocery chains?
    Yes, many major grocery chains carry crab cakes in their refrigerated or frozen seafood sections. Brands and availability may vary, so checking the store’s seafood department or website is recommended.

    Can I find fresh crab cakes at local seafood restaurants?
    Most local seafood restaurants offer freshly made crab cakes, often prepared with regional crab meat. It is advisable to inquire about their sourcing and preparation methods for quality assurance.

    Is it possible to buy crab cakes online for home delivery?
    Yes, numerous online seafood vendors specialize in shipping fresh or frozen crab cakes nationwide. Ensure the vendor uses proper packaging and expedited shipping to maintain freshness.

    What should I look for when buying crab cakes to ensure quality?
    Look for crab cakes with a high percentage of lump crab meat, minimal fillers, and no artificial preservatives. Freshness indicators and customer reviews can also guide quality assessment.

    Are there specialty stores that focus exclusively on crab cakes?
    Certain specialty seafood shops and deli stores focus on crab cakes and related products. These stores often offer a variety of styles and flavors, catering to diverse preferences.
    finding the best place to buy crab cakes involves considering factors such as freshness, quality of ingredients, and authenticity. Whether opting for specialty seafood markets, renowned local restaurants, or trusted online retailers, prioritizing sources known for their commitment to genuine crab meat and traditional recipes ensures a superior culinary experience. Additionally, understanding regional variations and customer reviews can guide buyers toward establishments that consistently deliver flavorful and well-crafted crab cakes.

    It is also important to evaluate convenience and availability when selecting where to purchase crab cakes. While local seafood shops and eateries offer immediate access and often the freshest options, online platforms provide a broader selection and the ability to explore gourmet varieties from different regions. Ensuring proper packaging and shipping methods is crucial when buying crab cakes online to maintain quality and taste upon delivery.

    Ultimately, the key takeaway is that informed choices based on quality, reputation, and customer feedback will lead to the best crab cake purchasing experience. Whether for personal enjoyment or special occasions, selecting a reputable source guarantees that the distinctive flavors and textures of authentic crab cakes are preserved and appreciated.

    Author Profile

    Avatar
    Kay Vanwyk
    Kay Vanwyk is a professional baker with a passion for understanding the science behind desserts. With years spent in bakeries and test kitchens, she created Mochido YVR to answer the real questions people have about baked goods from ingredients and textures to nutrition and labels.

    Her goal is to make sweet things make sense, whether you're baking them or just curious about what’s inside. Kay brings experience, clarity, and curiosity to every post she writes.